West Explosion: Not Enough Protections Or Not Enough Oversight?

Source: www.thenation.com

There’s been a lot of debate following the West tragedy as to whether a lack of safety protections, lack of coordination and oversight among enforcement agencies, or some combination of both contributed to a system wide failure and 14 deaths with hundreds injured. As we have mentioned before, Texas leads the nation in total fatal occupational injuries, with more than 400 deaths in 2011. And while not every accident can be prevented, it does seem that Texas gets more than its fair share.

In recent reports, some state officials have indicated that the state’s level of oversight for facilities like the one in West is adequate. It is difficult to understand how one could make such bold statements when the cause of the explosion has yet to be determined. Furthermore, some legislators have recommended this legislative session that state environmental laws be weakened. This is in addition to recent budget cuts at the state environmental agency; the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality’s (TCEQ) budget was recently cut by $305 million, which reduced the agency by 235 full-time employees. Perhaps what some of our officials really mean is that it is not a lack of oversight, but rather a lack of due diligence in enforcing the laws already on the books, laws designed to protect citizens from events like this one.

The Governor of Texas was quoted recently claiming that the state upholds the standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). But frankly that is not quite true. Acting alone, Texas recently refused to abide by laws on permitting regulations for greenhouse gas emissions.  In fact, the state sent an aggressive letter to EPA stating that “On behalf of the state of Texas, we write to inform you that Texas has neither the authority nor the intention of interpreting, ignoring, or amending its laws in order to compel the permitting of greenhouse gas emissions.”  EPA actually had to devise a federal implementation plan for greenhouse gas emissions, so that any new facilities built in the state of Texas could in fact work with a legal permit. Currently, facilities that need a greenhouse gas permit must apply to EPA rather than to TCEQ, even though it is Texas’ responsibility.

In assessing the causes of the West tragedy and whether they could have been prevented, it is worth asking these questions:

  • Would this have happened had state agencies been more diligent in making routine investigations?
  • Would this have happened had the state been more diligent in reporting the facility’s compliance history?
  • Would fewer people have died or fewer homes been destroyed if Texas had siting requirements limiting the distance between the community and the plant?

As the investigation into this tragedy continues, we’ll learn more about what might have helped to prevent it. My hope is that we’ll use what we learn to ensure that this tragedy never happens again. In the meantime, we owe a great deal of gratitude to the folks who deal with the fallout from catastrophes like West on a daily basis. Many of the 14 victims in the West, Texas fertilizer explosion were first responders, and many of them were volunteers.  Thank you to all of our doctors, nurses, EMTs, police officers and service men and women who work day in and day out to help save lives, especially in the face of uncertainties and dangers that may exist.

This entry was posted in Air Pollution, Environment, Environmental Protection Agency, Legislation, TCEQ. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

One Comment

  1. Posted April 28, 2013 at 9:11 PM | Permalink

    Cause of central Texas fertilizer plant explosion –
    From early reports, there was an initial fire which was fought with water. The water then reacted with stored anhydrous ammonia resulting in ammonium hydroxide and heat. The intense heat then ignited the ammonium nitrate resulting in the massive explosion.
    However, sometimes fires or even blasting caps fail to ignite ammonium nitrate because the energy of activation is so high to initiate the decomposition reaction.
    There was a rapid cold front sweeping through Texas just at the time of the explosion. A lightning strike in Oklahoma City set fire to an oil storage tank. There must have been an electromagnetic disturbance associated with the front.
    In addition, there was a Sun-Moon-Star symmetric pattern occurring at the same time. This pattern was similiar to that of the Gulf oilwell blowout which was also associated with a cold front immediately in the vicinity.
    Please check out the astronomical diagrams and the similarity of the Sun-Moon patterns for the explosion and the Gulf blowout:
    http://astrosymm.com/EXPLOSIONS.htm
    http://astrosymm.com/BLOWOUTS.htm
    Be sure to scroll all the way down the explosions page to catch the AZF, Oppau and Texas City ammonium nitrate explosions.

  • About This Blog

    Confluence of SJR, Old, and Middle rivers

    Advocating for healthier air and cleaner energy in Texas through public education and policy influence.

    Follow @EDFtx

  • Categories

  • Get blog posts by email

    Subscribe via RSS

  • Featured authors

    Ramon AlvarezRamon Alvarez
    Senior Scientist

    Elena Craft
    Health Scientist

    Jim Marston
    Vice President, US Climate and Energy Program

    Marita Mirzatuny
    Project Manager

    Marcelo Norsworthy
    Transportation Research Analyst

    Kate Zerrenner
    Project Manager

  • Twitter activity