How water managers can build recharge basins to boost resilience for farmers and birds alike

I wasn’t expecting to see egrets, herons and pelicans on my first trip to the San Joaquin Valley — a region in the southern part of California’s Central Valley known for its impressive agricultural production and scorching summer heat. I didn’t find these birds at one of the valley’s few wildlife refuges, but at a groundwater recharge facility designed to spread and infiltrate surface water into the ground below.

Recharge basins are becoming increasingly popular in overdrafted regions in California, where water managers are seeking solutions to balance groundwater supply and demand to comply with the state’s Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).

The multiple benefits of recharge basins

Water managers and farmers can use recharge basins — essentially man-made ponds or lakes — to capture excess runoff from increasingly intense winter storms. They can then store the water in the basin for future use or let it permeate into the ground to bolster groundwater levels and avoid issues such as land subsidence and domestic well failure.

While some recharge basins are dug deep and kept “clean” of plants, others like the one I visited mimic historic habitat, with features like shallow sloping basin floors and plant-covered islands.

EDF partnered with Point Blue Conservation Science, Audubon California and Sustainable Conservation to develop a guide for how to build this kind of preferred recharge basin that provides operational benefits to basin managers while also creating valuable waterbird habitat.

Proven success in delivering co-benefits

Sustainable Conservation has been working with California irrigation districts for the past five years to identify locations for recharge projects and make the most of available surface water supplies. Though the districts they work with are primarily focused on recharge efficiency and cost savings, Daniel Mountjoy, director of resource stewardship, noticed some managers incorporating multibenefit features.

“These managers found that planting basin floors was enhancing infiltration rates and that sloped basins and banks were less likely to plug up with fine sediments,” he explained. “These measures were taken to improve recharge efficiency, but they were also incidentally creating excellent waterbird habitat.” New guide will help water managers and growers build recharge basins that provide operational benefits while also creating valuable waterbird habitat. Click To Tweet

And it takes only modest adjustments to recharge basin design and management for these bodies of water to also serve as a much-needed network of habitat for migratory waterbirds. We’ve already seen this successful coupling of recharge and habitat in the Sacramento Valley, where The Nature Conservancy’s BirdReturns program has used an Airbnb model to create thousands of acres high quality habitat on flooded rice plains.

Groundwater recharge basins offer the opportunity to create more habitat for birds like these black-necked stilt frequently found in the Central Valley.

Surging interest provides new opportunities

With pressure to balance groundwater supply and demand mounting, there’s a surge in new plans for recharge basins and expansion of existing basins.

San Joaquin Valley water managers are already planning to build 15,000 acres of recharge basins in addition to the more than 30,000 acres already in place, according to a Point Blue study. Many anticipate even greater expansion in the coming years.

It’s important to note that, in California, the capacity of underground water storage — which these recharge basins enable — is estimated to be more than 20 times greater than the amount of currently available above-ground storage in reservoirs and lakes.

Some state and federal funding is available to support multibenefit recharge projects, but additional incentives and regulatory assurances are needed to kick-start adoption at a greater scale and create much-needed habitat in California.

California’s Central Valley has lost more than 90% of its wetlands in the last century. We know it’s impossible to re-create all of those wetlands, especially given the region’s crucial role growing healthy food for the world. But as SGMA sparks greater interest in building recharge basins, farmers and water managers have an opportunity to develop valuable bird habitat while continuing to produce food.

I hope this guide will provide helpful information and encourage water managers and landowners to seize this opportunity.

Watercolor of a flourishing recharge basin — a featured illustration in the guide.

This entry was posted in western water. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

2 Comments

  1. Posted March 17, 2020 at 2:09 pm | Permalink

    Using flood and seasonally high flows to recharge groundwater has great potential and should be pursued. As this is done, however, we need to think it though and consider all related impacts. Consider, for example, what will happen if irrigators and groundwater managers become dependent on diverting winter flows and we have a year (like 1977) where those high winter flows do not occur. What happens then? You can bet irrigators and water managers will then claim it is an emergency and they must divert the flows that are there. So it is important that, as folks rush to take flood flows, we think situations thorough and do things properly.

    Organizations like Sustainable Conservation should not just promote the benefits like more wetlands. Y’all should recognize and affirm that streams need periodic high flows in order to remain healthy and support all beneficial uses, including in-stream uses like fisheries. Please support the development of year-around streamflow criteria as essential information that must be considered before any winter flows are diverted to groundwater storage.

    • Anna Schiller
      Posted March 27, 2020 at 3:33 pm | Permalink

      Thank you for the comment. I definitely agree with your point that streams need high flows to support fisheries and other beneficial uses and that year-round standards are desirable. EDF will continue to work to achieve that. However, given that few streams have such standards in place now, we do not think we can rule out the possibility of new diversions for recharge when conditions are very wet, particularly since we are already implementing SGMA in many basins. Recharge needs to be done thoughtfully and systematically with an eye to protecting beneficial uses, including fish and wildlife. EDF supports the approach adopted by the State Water Resources Control Board to expedite permits to divert water for recharge during the rainy season when stream flow exceeds 90% of average flow on a given day. Our goal is to divert a fraction of high flows when conditions are very wet for the purpose of recharge, not to increase diversions under dry conditions.