On the Water Front

A water policy forum for the Golden State

Posts from September 2009

DWR puts it's support for the ESA in writing

Ann HaydenAnn Hayden is a Senior Water Resource Analyst at EDF.

After another week of attempts  to weaken the Endangered Species Act, EDF couldn't be happier to see Lester Snow, Director of the State's Department of Water Resources, put his support of the ESA in writing. See his letter to Senator Feinstein, Secretaries Salazar and Locke  here (PDF).  We're hoping to hear the same commitment from Secretary Salazar at the public hearing tomorrow.

Making the Delta Work Tomorrow: Recovering fish while supplying water reliably

Ann HaydenAnn Hayden is a Senior Water Resource Analyst at EDF.

The Bay-Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) may become the law of the land (and water) as early as 2011. If it does, how well will it protect endangered species? And how much water will be determined to be safely exported to the farms and cities that depend on Delta supplies before any major possible changes to habitat or infrastructure are implemented? Read more »

And now for the rest of the (Fox News) story

Spreck Rosekrans Spreck Rosekrans is an Economic Analyst at EDF.

The coverage of California water by Fox News Host Sean Hannity last night was disappointing. It was simplistic, one-sided, misleading and, in some cases, flat wrong. And perhaps most egregiously, the famously “small government” host delivered his message on behalf of wealthy farmers who owe their very existence to the federal handouts and are still deep in debt to United States taxpayers.

Let’s be fair. Mr. Hannity got some things right. He is correct that unemployment is particularly high in many towns in the San Joaquin Valley. The food lines and human suffering are real. In 2009, water deliveries to farming communities on the west side of the Valley have been significantly reduced. And part of that reduction is due to the Endangered Species Act protections designed to protect Delta smelt from extinction.

But Mr. Hannity does not tell the whole story. Read more »

Whither water?

Cynthia KoehlerCynthia Koehler is Senior Consulting Attorney for EDF.

The demise of a package of five water policy bills in the state legislature late Friday night, while predictable given end-of-session deadlines, had this sliver of surprise buried in it: the 5 policy bills taken together were pretty good. By “pretty good,” I mean good in the sense of “an important and meaningful advance over the water policy status quo for the environment” as opposed to “guaranteeing the water policy outcomes that would be ideal” from an environmental perspective.

How can the policy package possibly be construed as good, when it was linked to a water bond that included billions for construction of new dams under a poorly-defined assumption that they would provide public benefits?

Let’s stipulate that the longstanding practice in California of holding solid water policy reform hostage to a massive public spending commitment is of questionable wisdom at best. Read more »

The Wall Street Journal buys into a false choice

Spreck Rosekrans Spreck Rosekrans is an Economic Analyst at EDF.

The Wall Street Journal’s editorial “California’s Man-Made Drought” (Sept. 2), buys into the false choice of fish versus jobs. It is disappointing that the Journal, given its financial focus, fails to address or even acknowledge opportunities for market-based solutions to improve water use efficiency. The editorial also ignores many salient aspects of water management in California.

The WSJ seems to believe that the “pumps” are off (pumps which convey water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta to cities and farms to the south). The pumps were never “off” but pumping rates were reduced during spring months to protect endangered fish. While the legal rulings are in place due to concern over Delta smelt, it is only one of several species whose populations have plummeted in recent years as diversions of freshwater have reached record levels. The pumps are now at full capacity. Lester Snow, Director of California’s Department of Resources, estimated that protecting fish in the Delta reduced overall pumping only about 5% for the year. The largest reason for reduced deliveries is that California is in its third year of drought. Read more »

Suburbs versus farms

Spreck Rosekrans Spreck Rosekrans is an Economic Analyst at EDF.

The $77 million proposal to sell 14,000 acre-feet of the Central Valley’s agricultural water to suburban San Bernardino County puts a new twist on the debate over water use in California.

Throughout 2009, the third consecutive dry year in California, there has been unprecedented media focus on the effects that legal rulings to protect endangered fish in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta have had on water exports to farming communities with junior water rights on the west side of the San Joaquin Valley. The debate has been loud. Read more »

On the Water Front is powered by WordPress.

RSS feeds are available for posts and comments.

Confluence of SJR, Old, and Middle rivers

About This Blog

A balanced approach to western water policy—protecting California's ecosystems and providing reliable water supplies for our farms and cities.

Meet The Bloggers

Laura Harnish
California Regional Director

Kathryn Phillips
Director, California Transportation and Air Initiative

Spreck Rosekrans
Economic Analyst

Ann Hayden
Senior Water Resource Analyst

Cynthia Koehler
Senior Consulting Attorney

Ashley Rood
Research and Outreach Associate

Jennifer Witherspoon
California Communications Director

Subscribe to This Blog

By RSS feed or email:

Login