The Ruminant

A daily update on the debates shaping the 2007 Farm Bill

Freshmen Economics

There's only one group of Americans that generates more sympathy among congressional leaders than hungry kids, African farmers, struggling farmers, angry energy consumers, or the rural poor.

I refer, of course, to freshmen members of the House of Representatives.

The Ruminant is constantly touched by the outpouring of concern that our congressional leaders have for these new members of Congress.

Of course, these brave men and women don't go to bed hungry, or face starvation from low cotton prices, or face greater risk of diabetes.

But, they do have to face the voters. Imagine the anxiety!!!

So, the Ruminant, always a patriot, asked: how well would farmers respresented by Freshmen members of the House be served by USDA if Congress shifted some subsidies to help pay for USDA conservation programs.

The answer, in a report to be released at noon today, is that farmers in 36 of 55 districts represented by freshmen members would receive a fairer share of federal farm spending if Congress shifted direct payments to share the cost of clean water or wildlife habitat. Farmers in 12 districts would see little or no change. Many of these districts are located in California, Florida, Pennsylvania, New York and Ohio — large farm states that currently receive little support from USDA.

So, farmers in 48 of 55 districts would receive more support from USDA or see little or no change if Congress reformed farm subsidies to help the environment. Overall, many more more farmers would be able to participate in USDA programs.

There are seven districts where farmers would farmers would receive slightly federal spending — you know, the districts where corn and soybean prices have nearly doubled over the last two years in response to surging demand for ethanol. You know,the districts where large commercial farmers receive the lion's share of farm subsidies and generally vote for one party.

The Ruminant wonder whether Congressional leaders are making a big mistake if they throw consumers and the hungry under the bus to pander to a few fat cat farmers and their lobbyists. Rural voters overwhelmingly support reasonable subsidy reforms, like subsidy payment limits, because subsidizing fat cat farmers has hurt more farmers than it has helped.

And, what about those poor, suffering Freshmen members who represent farmers in California, Florida, New York, Ohio, and Pennsylvania? For some reason, fat cat farmers growing corn and soybeans in the square states are "real farmers" and the farmers who grow the food we actually eat are forgotten.

The Ruminant wonders whether they will be forgotten by the voters.

3 Responses

Comment from Kate
July 11th, 2007 at 4:44 pm

Hi there,

I made a response on this post

http://blogs.edf.org/healthyfarms/2007/06/26/subsidies-savings-accounts-and-and-small-farmers/

I would love to hear your response.

-Kate

Comment from Kate
July 11th, 2007 at 4:48 pm

oops! I meant this post!

http://blogs.edf.org/healthyfarms/2007/07/05/subsidies-snacks-and-sloppy-logic/

Sorry! They both started with the word "subsidies"

-Kate

Leave a Reply

Register an account so you don't have to type this in each time.
Login in to your account if you already have one.

Currently you have JavaScript disabled. In order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and reload the page. Click here for instructions on how to enable JavaScript in your browser.

User comments reflect the opinions of the responsible contributor only, and do not reflect the viewpoint of Environmental Defense Fund. We reserve the right to delete comments that may be considered offensive, illegal or inappropriate. We also reserve the right to delete duplicate comments, or comments that have no relationship to the original post.

The Ruminant is powered by WordPress.

RSS feeds are available for posts and comments.

About This Blog

The Ruminant is a daily update on the farm and food policy debates shaping the 2007 Farm Bill.

Login

Archives

Subscribe to This Blog

By RSS feed or email: