The Ruminant

A daily update on the debates shaping the 2007 Farm Bill

Millions for Millionaires?

Ever since the Dust Bowl, Americans have provided a safety net for our farmers. But, the creators of the "temporary" progam designed to lift farmers out of the Great Depression could not have imagined Maurice Wilder.

Wilder, a Florida developer, collected about $1.8 million in farm subsidies in 2005, according to the Environmental Working Group.

Wilder is not the only millionaire collecting farm subsidies. Loopholes in existing law allow farmers to easily evade limits on who can collect subsidies and how much they can collect.

A better course might be to gradually replace our outdated subsidies with a system of risk management accounts and revenue insurance tools. The Ruminant hopes House and Senate leaders will ruminate over promising new ideas.

Under a plan developed by Indiana Senator Richard Lugar , farmers would make a transition to a system of farmer-held risk management accounts that would help farmers weather the ups and downs of agriculture, make investments, and plan for the future.

In particular, subsidized crop farmers would be required to put a larger and larger share of their "direct" subsidy payments into risk management accounts. Farmers could contribute some of their own funds, but a match would not be required.

When sales fall below 95% of a farmer's average gross sales, a farmer can withdraw funds to cover the "shallow" losses that are not covered by revenue or crop insurance policies. Farmers could also withdraw funds to purchase crop or revenue insurance or to make investments in rural enterprises.

What's left in the account would serve as a farmer's IRA.

Given agriculture's success — due in no small measure to the growth of ethanol — and the dramatic expansion of crop and revenue insurance coverage, Congress finally has a chance to restructure and reduce the outdated subsidies that help few farmers and regions.

There's never been a better time to reform farm subsidies.

In 2007, farm income is expected to be $66.6 billion, up $8.8 billion from 2006 and $9 billion higher than the ten-year average. Average farm household income is nearly twice the amount of ordinary households and large commercial farms — the farms that collect the lion's share of farm subsidies — will enjoy household income greater than $270,000 this year.

Leave a Reply

Register an account so you don't have to type this in each time.
Login in to your account if you already have one.

Currently you have JavaScript disabled. In order to post comments, please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and reload the page. Click here for instructions on how to enable JavaScript in your browser.

User comments reflect the opinions of the responsible contributor only, and do not reflect the viewpoint of Environmental Defense Fund. We reserve the right to delete comments that may be considered offensive, illegal or inappropriate. We also reserve the right to delete duplicate comments, or comments that have no relationship to the original post.

The Ruminant is powered by WordPress.

RSS feeds are available for posts and comments.

About This Blog

The Ruminant is a daily update on the farm and food policy debates shaping the 2007 Farm Bill.

Archives

Subscribe to This Blog

By RSS feed or email: