On eve of Moscow meeting, new calculations reveal U.S. airlines could profit from EU cap on aviation emissions

By Annie Petsonk, International Counsel, and Adam Peltz, Legal Fellow

Next week, more than two dozen countries, including the United States, are meeting in Moscow to discuss their opposition to Europe’s pioneering law to cut global warming pollution from aviation.

U.S. airlines have said the EU's law that curbs aviation emissions will cost them billions, but new calculations show they could actually make money from it. (Thanks and photo credit to Flickr user DosenPhoto.)

On the agenda for the Moscow meeting are a number of topics that have been lobbied for by the U.S. aviation industry, which has said complying with the EU law will be too expensive.

U.S. airlines have been complaining for years that complying with the EU law will cost them billions of dollars, but we’ve also seen a slew of studies that show the airlines could save money – and even profit – by participating in the system.

So we commissioned EDF’s economics team to run some numbers.

When our economists compared 1] airlines’ projected 2012 emissions (based on the 2010 data they submitted to the EU and the industry’s projected 3% annual emissions growth rate), 2] data on the free emissions allowances the EU is giving to the airlines, and 3] current prices (from Feb. 15) for emissions credits in the EU carbon market with 4] the recent $3-per-leg fare increase the airlines added last month, we found that airlines that comply with the law can actually make money.

Based on these data:

  • United stands to turn a profit of $0.73 to $2.36 per ticket, or in the range of $88,000 to $287,000 a year on its flights from Washington, D.C. (Dulles) to Brussels.
  • American Airlines stands to reap anywhere from $1.15 to $2.50 per passenger, or $700,000 to $1.2 million a year on its flights from New York (JFK) to London Heathrow.
  • Delta Air Lines, which was the first carrier to impose a surcharge, could profit between $1.02 and $2.53 per ticket from Minneapolis, or $449,000 to $1.1 million annually on its Minneapolis to Amsterdam flight.

U.S. carriers aren't the only ones finding profit in the emissions cap; airlines around the world could be poised to profit, too:

  • Etihad Airways$3/ticket surcharge could net between $1.10 and $2.52 per passenger per flight* from Abu Dhabi to London.
  • AirAsia X's surcharge of $6.50 could produce a profit of $2.05 to $5.25 per passenger per flight* from Kuala Lumpur (Malaysia) to Paris.
  • Aeroflot Russian Airlines, if it matched United’s $3 fare increase, could make between $2.26 and $2.69 per ticket* on a typical flight from Moscow to Berlin.

(*These airlines’ ticket sales numbers are not publicly available so we are unable to calculate their potential annual profits.)

It’s critical to remember the purpose of the EU's law is to cut pollution. The aviation sector is growing so rapidly that, if emissions from aviation were left unregulated, they would quadruple from 2005 levels by 2050; the EU law will cut 183 metric tons of carbon dioxide annually by 2020, equivalent to taking 30 million cars off the road every year.

The data show that airlines’ claims of suffering a disproportionate burden and punitive costs to meet the cap are wrong. Savvy companies will see the law not as the burden that it isn’t, but as the opportunity that it is, and we would hope the airlines direct any profits to technology that can help them further reduce their emissions and fly cleaner and greener.

This entry was posted in Aviation, News. Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

7 Trackbacks

  • [...] Read more… [...]

  • [...] a practical standpoint, the estimated per-ticket cost of compliance with the EU ETS of less than $3 for a flight from New York to London pales in comparison to the [...]

  • By hotele zakopane on August 2, 2014 at 5:55 am

    hotele zakopane

    On eve of Moscow meeting, new calculations reveal U.S. airlines could profit from EU cap on aviation emissions | EDF Talks Global Climate

  • By rekuperator on August 2, 2014 at 9:00 am

    rekuperator

    On eve of Moscow meeting, new calculations reveal U.S. airlines could profit from EU cap on aviation emissions | EDF Talks Global Climate

  • By łóżka on August 5, 2014 at 6:20 pm

    łóżka

    On eve of Moscow meeting, new calculations reveal U.S. airlines could profit from EU cap on aviation emissions | EDF Talks Global Climate

  • By Papierosy elektroniczne on August 6, 2014 at 12:14 pm

    Papierosy elektroniczne

    On eve of Moscow meeting, new calculations reveal U.S. airlines could profit from EU cap on aviation emissions | EDF Talks Global Climate

  • By torba męska na ramię on November 3, 2014 at 1:44 am

    torba męska na ramię

    On eve of Moscow meeting, new calculations reveal U.S. airlines could profit from EU cap on aviation emissions | EDF Talks Global Climate

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Categories

  • Get blog posts by email

    Subscribe via RSS