Monthly Archives: May 2011

American, United, Continental Airlines "Greenwashing", say environmental groups

UPDATE JUNE 7   |   EDF has responded to a letter from the Air Transport Association of America (ATA). EDF’s response is here [PDF], and states that ATA’s letter

misses our key point: American and United/Continental are hypocritically and publicly touting their commitment to environmental protection while simultaneously working actively to undercut the world’s first program to reduce carbon pollution from aviation activities.

Below is our original post.

EDF joined five other major environmental groups today in denouncing American, United and Continental airlines for working to gut anti-pollution programs while simultaneously bragging about their environmental performances.

The companies each touted their environmental responsibility around Earth Day last month: American in an article in American Airlines in-flight magazine, and the newly merged United and Continental in the description of their new “Eco-Skies” environmental campaign.

Meanwhile, these airlines, along with the U.S. airlines trade group Air Transport Association of America, are suing in the European Court of Justice to block a new law that holds all airlines accountable for their global warming pollution resulting from flights to, from and within the European Union.

The companies are also lobbying the U.S. Congress to declare the EU law invalid.

Environmental groups urge airlines to drop lawsuit

In letters today to American Airlines Chairman and CEO Gerard J. Arpey and United Continental Holdings Inc. President and CEO Jeffrey A. Smisek, the environmental groups criticized the companies for

“spending [their] customers’ money on lawyers and lobbyists in an effort to thwart a crucial anti-pollution program”.

The groups that signed the letters – including Environmental Defense Fund, Center for Biological Diversity (CBD), Earthjustice, Environment America, Natural Resources Defense Council, and Sierra Club – urged the airlines to:

drop the lawsuit, and join the future of low-carbon aviation by making your actions consistent with your words.

The amount of global carbon emissions from aviation is expected to grow 3-4 percent per year.  EDF, CBD and Earthjustice have intervened in the litigation in support of the EU, as part of a trans-Atlantic coalition of environmental groups.  Oral argument for the case is expected in Fall 2011.

New EDF ads say American, United, Continental “dragging their wings” in cutting pollution

EDF submitted the above ad to United and Continental Airlines' Hemispheres magazine, and a similar one to the American Airlines' American Way magazine, urging the airlines to "start flying cleaner."

EDF today also submitted advertisements to American Airlines’ American Way and United/ Continental’s Hemispheres in-flight magazinesurging the airlines to start flying cleaner.

In its April 2011 in-flight magazine American Way, the American Airlines feature “AA Reduces Environmental Footprint” says the company is:

committed to identifying and implementing programs to reduce our environmental impact as well.”

The webpage for the new “Eco-Skies” campaign for the merged United and Continental Airlines says the airlines:

have shared a common focus on protecting the environment, which is allowing us to integrate our programs and focus on the environmental commitment of our combined company.”

These airlines, says EDF’s ad, are suing European governments over common-sense rules to save jet fuel and reduce pollution.  EDF’s ad says:

[G]iven a chance to cut pollution and save money, these airlines are dragging their wings…  Instead of wasting money on PR and lawsuits, why not join in the effort to make our world cleaner?”

EDF has requested the airlines respond within a week indicating whether the ads will be accepted for publication.

Posted in Aviation, News / 1 Response

EDF submits comments to New Zealand's emissions trading system review

New Zealand is currently conducting a review of its emissions trading system for greenhouse-gas pollutants, as required by the law that enacted the program.

EDF has submitted comments to New Zealand as it undergoes a review of its emissions trading system.  (Image: Yodod/Flickr)

EDF recently submitted comments for the review, because:

we believe that what happens in New Zealand can make a real difference to the global response to climate change. Historically, New Zealand has initiated important policy innovations that have been adopted around the world over time, from female enfranchisement to fisheries quota management systems. Again, the world is watching New Zealand…

Our comments focus on developments in carbon markets including California, Europe, and elsewhere, suggesting some enhancements that New Zealand policy-makers may wish to consider in the post-2012 environment.

In our submission, we also recommend the country pay particular attention to factors such as:

  • Flexibility and adaptability
  • Continued access to other carbon markets
  • Ongoing development of other carbon markets
  • Maintaining control and flexibility over the types of offsets which can be admitted into the New Zealand ETS
  • Environmental credibility of the market and its instruments

Read more about EDF's Submission to New Zealand’s Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) Review 2011.

Posted in Economics, News, Other, Uncategorized / Leave a comment